Skip to content

10 — Implementation Tiers (Essential / Standard / Advanced)

One framework, three ambition levels

Not every organisation needs every capability. Instead of maintaining three editions, OCDF uses a tier overlay (pattern borrowed from the CIS Controls' Implementation Groups): every capability is tagged with the lowest tier that should implement it. Higher tiers include everything below them.

Tier Who Rough profile
E — Essential SMEs, ≤5 security FTE, NIS2 important entities, low-complexity IT The defensible minimum; mostly Model A/hybrid operating models
S — Standard Dedicated CDC, NIS2 essential entities, regulated mid/large orgs Full six-function coverage with measurement
A — Advanced Critical infrastructure, high-threat sectors, DORA TLPT-scope entities Validation, automation and self-improvement

Tier ≠ maturity. Tier answers which capabilities; the maturity model answers how well you run them. A sensible target pairing: E-tier at Level 2, S-tier at Level 3, A-tier at Level 3–4.

Capability tier map

Function Essential (E) + Standard (S) + Advanced (A)
GOVERN GV-1 charter · GV-3 policies · GV-4 RACI · GV-7 basic reporting GV-2 risk integration · GV-5 resourcing governance · GV-6 supply chain Quantified risk; board exercises (L4 criteria)
IDENTIFY ID-1 inventory · ID-3 crown jewels · ID-4 basic vuln mgmt ID-2 data classification · ID-5 threat profile · ID-6 risk assessment · ID-7 improvement loop Continuous attack-surface mgmt; intel-driven engineering
PROTECT PR-1 MFA/least-priv · PR-2 awareness · PR-5 patching · PR-7 tested offline backups · PR-9 email/web basics (DMARC, DNS filtering) · script control & blocking execution from user-writable paths PR-3 data security · PR-4 hardening baselines incl. server allowlisting · PR-6 segmentation PR-8 secure SDLC · continuous control validation · workstation allowlisting
DETECT DE-1 sources 1–3 · DE-3 triage runbook (or MSSP equivalent with transparency) DE-2 use-case lifecycle · DE-4 coverage measurement · DE-7 integrity monitoring · network/NDR telemetry where unmanaged devices or flat segments exist DE-5 hunting · DE-6 systematic validation · detection-as-code (doc 14) · CTI programme (doc 15)
RESPOND RS-1 IR plan · RS-2 top-3 playbooks · RS-5 reporting machinery RS-3 forensics (retainer ok) · RS-4 pre-authorised containment · RS-7 annual exercises RS-6 crisis integration · automated containment with gates
RECOVER RC-1 recovery plans+RTO/RPO · RC-5 post-incident reviews RC-2 trusted restoration · RC-3 verified execution · RC-6 BCM integration Ransomware-scale recovery exercises; measured RTO attainment

How to use tiers

  1. Pick your tier honestly (regulatory category + threat exposure + team size). When in doubt between two, take the lower and reach maturity Level 2–3 there first — a solid E beats a hollow S.
  2. Filter the framework: in the self-assessment and navigator, skip capabilities above your tier — mark them "above tier" rather than "missing", so the score reflects your ambition, not an enterprise ideal.
  3. Regulatory floor: your national law may mandate S-tier items regardless of size (e.g., Denmark's energy-sector act pushes DETECT toward A). The annex + selector tool trump the tier map.
  4. Review the tier choice at every annual reassessment — tiers are meant to be outgrown.

Open CDC Framework (CC BY 4.0). Tier-overlay pattern inspired by CIS Critical Security Controls Implementation Groups (© Center for Internet Security), credited in 19-references.md.